{"_id": {"$oid": "6a1010f996d87b97b14cf8e6"}, "test_id": "T1037", "benchmark": "bibliographic_data", "date": "2026-04-27", "tags": {"document-type": ["book-page"], "writing": ["printed"], "century": [20], "language": ["en"], "layout": ["list"], "entry-type": ["bibliographic"], "task": ["information-extraction"]}, "contributors": ["pema_frick", "sven_burkhardt", "sorin_marti"], "hidden": false, "config": {"provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-23", "dataclass": "Document", "temperature": 0.0, "role_description": "You are a Historian", "legacy_test": false}, "prompt": null, "results": {"text": "{\"metadata\":{\"title\":\"1946\",\"year\":\"1946\",\"page_number\":4},\"entries\":[{\"id\":\"34\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"Der Sinn der Geschichte\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Baeck\",\"given\":\"Leo\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Habel\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Berlin\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"35\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"The Art of Writing History\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Bryant\",\"given\":\"Arthur\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Oxford University Press\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Oxford\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"36\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"Historia y destino\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Ca\u00f1al Barrachina\",\"given\":\"Avelino\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Ucar, Garcia\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Havana\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"37\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Collingwood\",\"given\":\"R. G.\"}],\"note\":\"In German: Philosophie der Geschichte, translated by Gertrud Herding, Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1955.\",\"publisher\":\"Clarendon\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Oxford\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"38\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Hibbert Journal\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Webb\",\"given\":\"C. C. J.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XLV\",\"page\":\"83-86\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"39\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Canadian Historical Review\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Flenley\",\"given\":\"R.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVIII\",\"page\":\"68-72\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"40\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Journal of Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Mandelbaum\",\"given\":\"M.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XLIV\",\"page\":\"184-188\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"41\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophical Review\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Murphy\",\"given\":\"A. E.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"LVI\",\"page\":\"587-592\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"42\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Discussion: R. G. Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Walsh\",\"given\":\"W. H.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXII\",\"page\":\"153-160\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"43\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Logic and History\",\"container_title\":\"Australasian Journal of Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Buchdahl\",\"given\":\"G.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1948\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVI\",\"page\":\"94-114\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"44\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"On Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\",\"container_title\":\"Review of Metaphysics\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Strauss\",\"given\":\"Leo\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"V\",\"page\":\"559-586\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"45\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"The \u2018Objects\u2019 of Historical Knowledge\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Gardiner\",\"given\":\"P. L.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVII\",\"page\":\"211-220\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"46\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"History\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Harris\",\"given\":\"R. W.\"}],\"note\":\"N. S.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXXVII\",\"page\":\"1-7\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"47\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Metaphysics, History, and Civilization: Collingwood\u2019s Account of Their Interrelationship\",\"container_title\":\"Journal of Religion\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Hartt\",\"given\":\"J. N.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1953\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXXIII\",\"page\":\"198-211\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"48\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood and the Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"University of Toronto Quarterly\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Schneider\",\"given\":\"Frederick D.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952-53\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXII\",\"page\":\"172-183\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null}]}", "model": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-23", "provider": "openai", "finish_reason": "stop", "usage": {"input_tokens": 3660, "output_tokens": 2198, "total_tokens": 5858, "input_cost_usd": 0.0183, "output_cost_usd": 0.06594, "estimated_cost_usd": 0.08424}, "duration": 25.82186770439148, "timestamp": "2026-04-27T09:32:20.956349", "parsed": {"metadata": {"title": "1946", "year": "1946", "page_number": 4}, "entries": [{"id": "34", "type": "book", "title": "Der Sinn der Geschichte", "container_title": null, "author": [{"family": "Baeck", "given": "Leo"}], "note": null, "publisher": "Habel", "editor": null, "publisher_place": "Berlin", "issued": "1946", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": null, "volume": null, "page": null, "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "35", "type": "book", "title": "The Art of Writing History", "container_title": null, "author": [{"family": "Bryant", "given": "Arthur"}], "note": null, "publisher": "Oxford University Press", "editor": null, "publisher_place": "Oxford", "issued": "1946", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": null, "volume": null, "page": null, "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "36", "type": "book", "title": "Historia y destino", "container_title": null, "author": [{"family": "Ca\u00f1al Barrachina", "given": "Avelino"}], "note": null, "publisher": "Ucar, Garcia", "editor": null, "publisher_place": "Havana", "issued": "1946", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": null, "volume": null, "page": null, "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "37", "type": "book", "title": "The Idea of History", "container_title": null, "author": [{"family": "Collingwood", "given": "R. G."}], "note": "In German: Philosophie der Geschichte, translated by Gertrud Herding, Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1955.", "publisher": "Clarendon", "editor": null, "publisher_place": "Oxford", "issued": "1946", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": null, "volume": null, "page": null, "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "38", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Review of The Idea of History", "container_title": "Hibbert Journal", "author": [{"family": "Webb", "given": "C. C. J."}], "note": "Review.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1946", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XLV", "page": "83-86", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "39", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History", "container_title": "Canadian Historical Review", "author": [{"family": "Flenley", "given": "R."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1947", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXVIII", "page": "68-72", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "40", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Review of The Idea of History", "container_title": "Journal of Philosophy", "author": [{"family": "Mandelbaum", "given": "M."}], "note": "Review.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1947", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XLIV", "page": "184-188", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "41", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Review of The Idea of History", "container_title": "Philosophical Review", "author": [{"family": "Murphy", "given": "A. E."}], "note": "Review.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1947", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "LVI", "page": "587-592", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "42", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Discussion: R. G. Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History", "container_title": "Philosophy", "author": [{"family": "Walsh", "given": "W. H."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1947", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXII", "page": "153-160", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "43", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Logic and History", "container_title": "Australasian Journal of Philosophy", "author": [{"family": "Buchdahl", "given": "G."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1948", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXVI", "page": "94-114", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "44", "type": "journal-article", "title": "On Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History", "container_title": "Review of Metaphysics", "author": [{"family": "Strauss", "given": "Leo"}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1952", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "V", "page": "559-586", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "45", "type": "journal-article", "title": "The \u2018Objects\u2019 of Historical Knowledge", "container_title": "Philosophy", "author": [{"family": "Gardiner", "given": "P. L."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1952", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXVII", "page": "211-220", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "46", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History", "container_title": "History", "author": [{"family": "Harris", "given": "R. W."}], "note": "N. S.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1952", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXXVII", "page": "1-7", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "47", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Metaphysics, History, and Civilization: Collingwood\u2019s Account of Their Interrelationship", "container_title": "Journal of Religion", "author": [{"family": "Hartt", "given": "J. N."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1953", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXXIII", "page": "198-211", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}, {"id": "48", "type": "journal-article", "title": "Collingwood and the Idea of History", "container_title": "University of Toronto Quarterly", "author": [{"family": "Schneider", "given": "Frederick D."}], "note": "Review article.", "publisher": null, "editor": null, "publisher_place": null, "issued": "1952-53", "event_date": null, "related": null, "relation": "37", "volume": "XXII", "page": "172-183", "fascicle": null, "reprint": null, "edition": null, "incomplete": null}]}, "conversation_id": "ebbf8f40-16c9-42ad-9b06-42a8454f6b61", "score": {"fuzzy": 0.8864233847099021}, "raw_response": "{\"id\":\"chatcmpl-DZAjcwHq9rxUXQRmNTlgt50zo4c1j\",\"choices\":[{\"finish_reason\":\"stop\",\"index\":0,\"logprobs\":null,\"message\":{\"content\":\"{\\\"entries\\\":[{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Baeck\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Leo\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":null,\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"34\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"note\\\":null,\\\"page\\\":null,\\\"publisher\\\":\\\"Habel\\\",\\\"publisher_place\\\":\\\"Berlin\\\",\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":null,\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Der Sinn der Geschichte\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"book\\\",\\\"volume\\\":null},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Bryant\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Arthur\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":null,\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"35\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"note\\\":null,\\\"page\\\":null,\\\"publisher\\\":\\\"Oxford University Press\\\",\\\"publisher_place\\\":\\\"Oxford\\\",\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":null,\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"The Art of Writing History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"book\\\",\\\"volume\\\":null},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Ca\u00f1al Barrachina\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Avelino\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":null,\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"36\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"note\\\":null,\\\"page\\\":null,\\\"publisher\\\":\\\"Ucar, Garcia\\\",\\\"publisher_place\\\":\\\"Havana\\\",\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":null,\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Historia y destino\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"book\\\",\\\"volume\\\":null},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Collingwood\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"R. G.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":null,\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"In German: Philosophie der Geschichte, translated by Gertrud Herding, Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1955.\\\",\\\"page\\\":null,\\\"publisher\\\":\\\"Clarendon\\\",\\\"publisher_place\\\":\\\"Oxford\\\",\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":null,\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"The Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"book\\\",\\\"volume\\\":null},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Webb\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"C. C. J.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Hibbert Journal\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"38\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"83-86\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Review of The Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XLV\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Flenley\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"R.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Canadian Historical Review\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"39\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1947\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"68-72\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXVIII\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Mandelbaum\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"M.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Journal of Philosophy\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"40\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1947\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"184-188\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Review of The Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XLIV\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Murphy\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"A. E.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Philosophical Review\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"41\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1947\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"587-592\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Review of The Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"LVI\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Walsh\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"W. H.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Philosophy\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"42\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1947\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"153-160\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Discussion: R. G. Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXII\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Buchdahl\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"G.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Australasian Journal of Philosophy\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"43\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1948\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"94-114\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Logic and History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXVI\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Strauss\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Leo\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Review of Metaphysics\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"44\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1952\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"559-586\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"On Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"V\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Gardiner\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"P. L.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Philosophy\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"45\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1952\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"211-220\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"The \u2018Objects\u2019 of Historical Knowledge\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXVII\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Harris\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"R. W.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"History\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"46\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1952\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"N. S.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"1-7\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXXVII\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Hartt\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"J. N.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"Journal of Religion\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"47\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1953\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"198-211\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Metaphysics, History, and Civilization: Collingwood\u2019s Account of Their Interrelationship\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXXIII\\\"},{\\\"author\\\":[{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Schneider\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Frederick D.\\\"}],\\\"container_title\\\":\\\"University of Toronto Quarterly\\\",\\\"edition\\\":null,\\\"editor\\\":null,\\\"event_date\\\":null,\\\"fascicle\\\":null,\\\"id\\\":\\\"48\\\",\\\"incomplete\\\":null,\\\"issued\\\":\\\"1952-53\\\",\\\"note\\\":\\\"Review article.\\\",\\\"page\\\":\\\"172-183\\\",\\\"publisher\\\":null,\\\"publisher_place\\\":null,\\\"related\\\":null,\\\"relation\\\":\\\"37\\\",\\\"reprint\\\":null,\\\"title\\\":\\\"Collingwood and the Idea of History\\\",\\\"type\\\":\\\"journal-article\\\",\\\"volume\\\":\\\"XXII\\\"}],\\\"metadata\\\":{\\\"page_number\\\":4,\\\"title\\\":\\\"1946\\\",\\\"year\\\":\\\"1946\\\"}}\",\"refusal\":null,\"role\":\"assistant\",\"annotations\":[],\"audio\":null,\"function_call\":null,\"tool_calls\":null,\"parsed\":{\"metadata\":{\"title\":\"1946\",\"year\":\"1946\",\"page_number\":4},\"entries\":[{\"id\":\"34\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"Der Sinn der Geschichte\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Baeck\",\"given\":\"Leo\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Habel\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Berlin\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"35\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"The Art of Writing History\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Bryant\",\"given\":\"Arthur\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Oxford University Press\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Oxford\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"36\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"Historia y destino\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Ca\u00f1al Barrachina\",\"given\":\"Avelino\"}],\"note\":null,\"publisher\":\"Ucar, Garcia\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Havana\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"37\",\"type\":\"book\",\"title\":\"The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":null,\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Collingwood\",\"given\":\"R. G.\"}],\"note\":\"In German: Philosophie der Geschichte, translated by Gertrud Herding, Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1955.\",\"publisher\":\"Clarendon\",\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":\"Oxford\",\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":null,\"volume\":null,\"page\":null,\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"38\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Hibbert Journal\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Webb\",\"given\":\"C. C. J.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1946\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XLV\",\"page\":\"83-86\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"39\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Canadian Historical Review\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Flenley\",\"given\":\"R.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVIII\",\"page\":\"68-72\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"40\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Journal of Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Mandelbaum\",\"given\":\"M.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XLIV\",\"page\":\"184-188\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"41\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Review of The Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophical Review\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Murphy\",\"given\":\"A. E.\"}],\"note\":\"Review.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"LVI\",\"page\":\"587-592\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"42\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Discussion: R. G. Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Walsh\",\"given\":\"W. H.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1947\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXII\",\"page\":\"153-160\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"43\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Logic and History\",\"container_title\":\"Australasian Journal of Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Buchdahl\",\"given\":\"G.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1948\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVI\",\"page\":\"94-114\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"44\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"On Collingwood\u2019s Philosophy of History\",\"container_title\":\"Review of Metaphysics\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Strauss\",\"given\":\"Leo\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"V\",\"page\":\"559-586\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"45\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"The \u2018Objects\u2019 of Historical Knowledge\",\"container_title\":\"Philosophy\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Gardiner\",\"given\":\"P. L.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXVII\",\"page\":\"211-220\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"46\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood\u2019s Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"History\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Harris\",\"given\":\"R. W.\"}],\"note\":\"N. S.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXXVII\",\"page\":\"1-7\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"47\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Metaphysics, History, and Civilization: Collingwood\u2019s Account of Their Interrelationship\",\"container_title\":\"Journal of Religion\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Hartt\",\"given\":\"J. N.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1953\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXXIII\",\"page\":\"198-211\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null},{\"id\":\"48\",\"type\":\"journal-article\",\"title\":\"Collingwood and the Idea of History\",\"container_title\":\"University of Toronto Quarterly\",\"author\":[{\"family\":\"Schneider\",\"given\":\"Frederick D.\"}],\"note\":\"Review article.\",\"publisher\":null,\"editor\":null,\"publisher_place\":null,\"issued\":\"1952-53\",\"event_date\":null,\"related\":null,\"relation\":\"37\",\"volume\":\"XXII\",\"page\":\"172-183\",\"fascicle\":null,\"reprint\":null,\"edition\":null,\"incomplete\":null}]}}}],\"created\":1777275116,\"model\":\"gpt-5.5-2026-04-23\",\"object\":\"chat.completion\",\"service_tier\":\"default\",\"system_fingerprint\":null,\"usage\":{\"completion_tokens\":2198,\"prompt_tokens\":3660,\"total_tokens\":5858,\"completion_tokens_details\":{\"accepted_prediction_tokens\":0,\"audio_tokens\":0,\"reasoning_tokens\":512,\"rejected_prediction_tokens\":0},\"prompt_tokens_details\":{\"audio_tokens\":0,\"cached_tokens\":0}}}"}, "scoring": {"fuzzy": 0.715513093933812, "cost_summary": {"total_input_tokens": 18111, "total_output_tokens": 15203, "total_tokens": 33314, "input_cost_usd": 0.090555, "output_cost_usd": 0.45609, "total_cost_usd": 0.546645}}, "normalized_score": 71.5513093933812}