{"_id": {"$oid": "6a8456c1ef0a19c343227d25"}, "test_id": "T1555", "benchmark": "bibliographic_data", "date": "2026-08-15", "tags": {"document-type": ["book-page"], "writing": ["printed"], "century": [20], "language": ["en"], "layout": ["list"], "entry-type": ["bibliographic"], "task": ["information-extraction"]}, "contributors": ["pema_frick", "sven_burkhardt", "sorin_marti"], "hidden": false, "config": {"provider": "huggingface", "model": "thinkingmachines/Inkling:together", "dataclass": "Document", "temperature": 0.0, "role_description": "You are a Historian", "legacy_test": false}, "prompt": null, "results": {"text": "We need parse image page 10 (actually page number printed 9? Wait additional info says page number of this page is 10. The printed page number at top right is 9, but we should use 10 for metadata page_number? The schema has metadata with title, year, page_number. Need determine title and year. The header shows \"1947 BIBLIOGRAPHY 9\". So year 1947, title \"BIBLIOGRAPHY\". Page number given as 10. So metadata: {\"title\":\"BIBLIOGRAPHY\",\"year\":\"1947\",\"page_number\":10}.\n\nNow need extract entries 140-160, with possible incomplete last entry 160? Let's examine image carefully.\n\nEntries:\n140 Smellie, K. B., Why We Read History, London: P. Elek.\n141 Toynbee, Arnold J., A Study of History, abridged by D. C. Somervell, New York: Oxford (Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History).\n142 Verberne, L. G. J., In den spiegel van het verleden: historische opstellen, Utrecht, Antwerpen: Bruna.\n143 Vevir, Jos\u00e9, Esquemas de metodolog\u00eda eclesi\u00e1stica, Barcelona: Instituto.\n144 Walz, Hans H., Sinn und Ziel der Geschichte, Bonn: Universit\u00e4ts-Verlag.\n\nThen section \"Articles\"\n\n145 Atti del congresso internazionale di filosofia 15-20 November, 1946, Milano: Castellani.\nRelevant articles:\n146 Pietro C. Drago, \"Storia e materialismo storico\", vol. I, 109-117.\n147 Vito Fazio-Allmayer, \"Critica del giudizio storico\", vol. I, 281-290.\n148 A. Nyman, \"Forza e spirito nella storia\", vol. I, 191-200.\n149 Benjamin, Walter, \"Sur le concept d'histoire\", Les temps modernes II, 623-634.\n150 Boodin, John E., \"Philosophy of History\", in Dagobert D. Runes, ed., 20th Century Philosophy, New York: Philosophical Library, 89-106.\n151 Caillois, R. P., \"De la perception \u00e0 l'histoire. La philosophie de M. Merleau-Ponty\", Deucation II, 57-85. (Note \"Deucation\"? Actually \"Deucation\"? Let's keep as printed.)\n152 Cantimori, Delio, \"Commemorazione di Adolfo Omodeo\", Annali della Scuola Normale di Pisa, fasc. 3-4; (reprinted in D. Cantimori, Studi di storia, Torino: Einaudi, 1959).\n153 Cowan, Thomas, \"The Historian and the Philosophy of Science\", Isis XXXVIII, 11-18.\n154 Crawford, R. M., \"History as a Science\", Historical Studies: Australia and New Zealand III, 153-175.\n155 Danielou, J., \"Christianisme et histoire\", Etudes CCLIV, 166-184.\n156 Dell, Stanley, \"Wahrheit der Geschichte. Geschichte der Wahrheit\", Amerikanische Rundschau III, 44-53.\n157 Fay, Sidney B., \"The Idea of Progress\", American Historical Review LII, 231-246.\n158 Fessard, Gaston, \"Th\u00e9ologie et histoire\", Dieu vivant VIII, 39-65.\n159 Fish, Andrew, \"Acton, Creighton, and Lea: a Study in History and Ethics\", Pacific Historical Review XVI, 59-69.\n160 Garosci, A., \"Le conscience historique en Italie\", Les temps modernes III, 23-24.\n\nNeed determine types: likely \"book\" for 140-144, \"other\" or \"journal-article\"? The schema allows book, journal-article, other. For articles section, entry 145 is maybe \"other\" (conference proceedings?). Entries 146-160 are journal articles? Actually they are articles within volumes/journals. So type \"journal-article\". For 145, it's conference proceedings published? Could be \"other\" or \"book\". Let's assign \"other\" for conference proceedings? But maybe \"book\". Let's think. The schema requires one of enum. We'll assign 145 as \"other\" since it's conference acts. Or \"book\"? Let's see context: \"Atti del congresso...\" published Milano: Castellani. That sounds like a book of proceedings. Could be \"book\". But then \"Relevant articles:\" lists articles within it. So 145 is container, and 146-149 are articles in vol. I of that container? Actually 146-149 cite vol. I, 109-117 etc. So they are related to 145? The instruction: \"If an entry reviews another entry, the relation field should contain the id of the reviewed entry.\" Not exactly this. But maybe 146-149 are part of 145? However they have their own entries. There's no explicit relation field required except if reviews another entry. So we can leave relation null.\n\nBut need check if any entry reviews another. Doesn't seem so.\n\nNeed parse authors correctly with family and given.\n\nLet's list precisely with fields:\n\nEntry 140:\nid \"140\"\ntype \"book\"\ntitle \"Why We Read History\"\nauthor: [{\"family\":\"Smellie\",\"given\":\"K. B.\"}]\npublisher \"P. Elek\"\npublisher_place \"London\"\nincomplete false? Not last? Actually 140 is not last on page? Wait page ends at 160, but 140 is not last entry on page. Only last entry on page might be incomplete. The last entry visible is 160, which seems complete? Let's check: \"Garosci, A., \"Le conscience historique en Italie\", Les temps modernes III, 23-24.\" That looks complete, no continuation indicated. But the instruction says \"The last entry on a page might be incomplete. This means that the entry continues on the next page. If so, set the incomplete field to true.\" Since 160 ends with page range 23-24 and no indication of continuation, likely incomplete false. However sometimes the last entry on page is cut off in image? Here 160 is fully visible at bottom. So incomplete false for all? Wait but they said \"The last entry on a page might be incomplete.\" We need check if entry 160 is cut off? The image shows entry 160 fully, then blank space. So not incomplete.\n\nBut wait page number is 10, and printed page is 9. The entries go from 140 to 160. The last entry 160 might continue? No, looks complete.\n\nThus all entries have incomplete null or false? The schema allows boolean or null. We'll set false? Or null? The instruction: \"If so, set the incomplete field to true.\" So if not, we can omit or set false/null. Let's set null for all except if true. But easier set false? The schema allows boolean or null. Let's use null for non-incomplete, but maybe false is okay. Let's use null except true.\n\nNow parse each entry with correct fields.\n\n140:\nauthor: Smellie, K. B. => family \"Smellie\", given \"K. B.\"\ntitle: \"Why We Read History\"\npublisher_place: \"London\"\npublisher: \"P. Elek\"\nNo container, volume, page, etc.\n\n141:\nauthor: Toynbee, Arnold J. => family \"Toynbee\", given \"Arnold J.\"\ntitle: \"A Study of History\"\nnote? There's \"abridged by D. C. Somervell\" => maybe editor? Actually abridged by is like editor? The schema has editor field (array of strings). So editor: [\"D. C. Somervell\"]? Or note? Let's put in note? But there is specific \"abridged by D. C. Somervell, New York: Oxford (Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History).\" The publisher is Oxford? Actually \"New York: Oxford\" => publisher_place \"New York\", publisher \"Oxford\". The parenthetical \"(Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History)\" is part of title? Or note? Let's include in title? Actually title is \"A Study of History\". The rest is publication info and note. Let's parse:\npublisher_place: \"New York\"\npublisher: \"Oxford\"\neditor: [\"D. C. Somervell\"]? The field is \"editor\" array of strings. Yes, abridged by can be considered editor.\nnote: \"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\" maybe in note.\nBut also there is \"(Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History)\" right after publisher. Let's assign note: \"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\". Or include in title? Probably note.\n\nLet's do:\nid \"141\"\ntype \"book\"\ntitle \"A Study of History\"\nauthor [{\"family\":\"Toynbee\",\"given\":\"Arnold J.\"}]\neditor [\"D. C. Somervell\"]\npublisher \"Oxford\"\npublisher_place \"New York\"\nnote \"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\"\n\n142:\nauthor Verberne, L. G. J. => family \"Verberne\", given \"L. G. J.\"\ntitle \"In den spiegel van het verleden: historische opstellen\"\npublisher_place \"Utrecht, Antwerpen\"\npublisher \"Bruna\"\ntype \"book\"\n\n143:\nauthor Vevir, Jos\u00e9 => family \"Vevir\", given \"Jos\u00e9\"\ntitle \"Esquemas de metodolog\u00eda eclesi\u00e1stica\"\npublisher_place \"Barcelona\"\npublisher \"Instituto\"\ntype \"book\"\n\n144:", "model": "thinkingmachines/Inkling", "provider": "huggingface", "finish_reason": "length", "usage": {"input_tokens": 2697, "output_tokens": 2048, "total_tokens": 4745, "input_cost_usd": 0.002697, "output_cost_usd": 0.008294399999999999, "estimated_cost_usd": 0.010991399999999998}, "duration": 47.01479387283325, "timestamp": "2026-08-15T16:26:02.235093", "conversation_id": "9a19f68a-204b-4fca-98e0-15916d2baa82", "score": {"fuzzy": 0.0}, "raw_response": "{\"id\":\"owJkXf1-31r7CA-a2b8decc79a5d6e1\",\"choices\":[{\"finish_reason\":\"length\",\"index\":0,\"logprobs\":null,\"message\":{\"content\":\"We need parse image page 10 (actually page number printed 9? Wait additional info says page number of this page is 10. The printed page number at top right is 9, but we should use 10 for metadata page_number? The schema has metadata with title, year, page_number. Need determine title and year. The header shows \\\"1947 BIBLIOGRAPHY 9\\\". So year 1947, title \\\"BIBLIOGRAPHY\\\". Page number given as 10. So metadata: {\\\"title\\\":\\\"BIBLIOGRAPHY\\\",\\\"year\\\":\\\"1947\\\",\\\"page_number\\\":10}.\\n\\nNow need extract entries 140-160, with possible incomplete last entry 160? Let's examine image carefully.\\n\\nEntries:\\n140 Smellie, K. B., Why We Read History, London: P. Elek.\\n141 Toynbee, Arnold J., A Study of History, abridged by D. C. Somervell, New York: Oxford (Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History).\\n142 Verberne, L. G. J., In den spiegel van het verleden: historische opstellen, Utrecht, Antwerpen: Bruna.\\n143 Vevir, Jos\u00e9, Esquemas de metodolog\u00eda eclesi\u00e1stica, Barcelona: Instituto.\\n144 Walz, Hans H., Sinn und Ziel der Geschichte, Bonn: Universit\u00e4ts-Verlag.\\n\\nThen section \\\"Articles\\\"\\n\\n145 Atti del congresso internazionale di filosofia 15-20 November, 1946, Milano: Castellani.\\nRelevant articles:\\n146 Pietro C. Drago, \\\"Storia e materialismo storico\\\", vol. I, 109-117.\\n147 Vito Fazio-Allmayer, \\\"Critica del giudizio storico\\\", vol. I, 281-290.\\n148 A. Nyman, \\\"Forza e spirito nella storia\\\", vol. I, 191-200.\\n149 Benjamin, Walter, \\\"Sur le concept d'histoire\\\", Les temps modernes II, 623-634.\\n150 Boodin, John E., \\\"Philosophy of History\\\", in Dagobert D. Runes, ed., 20th Century Philosophy, New York: Philosophical Library, 89-106.\\n151 Caillois, R. P., \\\"De la perception \u00e0 l'histoire. La philosophie de M. Merleau-Ponty\\\", Deucation II, 57-85. (Note \\\"Deucation\\\"? Actually \\\"Deucation\\\"? Let's keep as printed.)\\n152 Cantimori, Delio, \\\"Commemorazione di Adolfo Omodeo\\\", Annali della Scuola Normale di Pisa, fasc. 3-4; (reprinted in D. Cantimori, Studi di storia, Torino: Einaudi, 1959).\\n153 Cowan, Thomas, \\\"The Historian and the Philosophy of Science\\\", Isis XXXVIII, 11-18.\\n154 Crawford, R. M., \\\"History as a Science\\\", Historical Studies: Australia and New Zealand III, 153-175.\\n155 Danielou, J., \\\"Christianisme et histoire\\\", Etudes CCLIV, 166-184.\\n156 Dell, Stanley, \\\"Wahrheit der Geschichte. Geschichte der Wahrheit\\\", Amerikanische Rundschau III, 44-53.\\n157 Fay, Sidney B., \\\"The Idea of Progress\\\", American Historical Review LII, 231-246.\\n158 Fessard, Gaston, \\\"Th\u00e9ologie et histoire\\\", Dieu vivant VIII, 39-65.\\n159 Fish, Andrew, \\\"Acton, Creighton, and Lea: a Study in History and Ethics\\\", Pacific Historical Review XVI, 59-69.\\n160 Garosci, A., \\\"Le conscience historique en Italie\\\", Les temps modernes III, 23-24.\\n\\nNeed determine types: likely \\\"book\\\" for 140-144, \\\"other\\\" or \\\"journal-article\\\"? The schema allows book, journal-article, other. For articles section, entry 145 is maybe \\\"other\\\" (conference proceedings?). Entries 146-160 are journal articles? Actually they are articles within volumes/journals. So type \\\"journal-article\\\". For 145, it's conference proceedings published? Could be \\\"other\\\" or \\\"book\\\". Let's assign \\\"other\\\" for conference proceedings? But maybe \\\"book\\\". Let's think. The schema requires one of enum. We'll assign 145 as \\\"other\\\" since it's conference acts. Or \\\"book\\\"? Let's see context: \\\"Atti del congresso...\\\" published Milano: Castellani. That sounds like a book of proceedings. Could be \\\"book\\\". But then \\\"Relevant articles:\\\" lists articles within it. So 145 is container, and 146-149 are articles in vol. I of that container? Actually 146-149 cite vol. I, 109-117 etc. So they are related to 145? The instruction: \\\"If an entry reviews another entry, the relation field should contain the id of the reviewed entry.\\\" Not exactly this. But maybe 146-149 are part of 145? However they have their own entries. There's no explicit relation field required except if reviews another entry. So we can leave relation null.\\n\\nBut need check if any entry reviews another. Doesn't seem so.\\n\\nNeed parse authors correctly with family and given.\\n\\nLet's list precisely with fields:\\n\\nEntry 140:\\nid \\\"140\\\"\\ntype \\\"book\\\"\\ntitle \\\"Why We Read History\\\"\\nauthor: [{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Smellie\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"K. B.\\\"}]\\npublisher \\\"P. Elek\\\"\\npublisher_place \\\"London\\\"\\nincomplete false? Not last? Actually 140 is not last on page? Wait page ends at 160, but 140 is not last entry on page. Only last entry on page might be incomplete. The last entry visible is 160, which seems complete? Let's check: \\\"Garosci, A., \\\"Le conscience historique en Italie\\\", Les temps modernes III, 23-24.\\\" That looks complete, no continuation indicated. But the instruction says \\\"The last entry on a page might be incomplete. This means that the entry continues on the next page. If so, set the incomplete field to true.\\\" Since 160 ends with page range 23-24 and no indication of continuation, likely incomplete false. However sometimes the last entry on page is cut off in image? Here 160 is fully visible at bottom. So incomplete false for all? Wait but they said \\\"The last entry on a page might be incomplete.\\\" We need check if entry 160 is cut off? The image shows entry 160 fully, then blank space. So not incomplete.\\n\\nBut wait page number is 10, and printed page is 9. The entries go from 140 to 160. The last entry 160 might continue? No, looks complete.\\n\\nThus all entries have incomplete null or false? The schema allows boolean or null. We'll set false? Or null? The instruction: \\\"If so, set the incomplete field to true.\\\" So if not, we can omit or set false/null. Let's set null for all except if true. But easier set false? The schema allows boolean or null. Let's use null for non-incomplete, but maybe false is okay. Let's use null except true.\\n\\nNow parse each entry with correct fields.\\n\\n140:\\nauthor: Smellie, K. B. => family \\\"Smellie\\\", given \\\"K. B.\\\"\\ntitle: \\\"Why We Read History\\\"\\npublisher_place: \\\"London\\\"\\npublisher: \\\"P. Elek\\\"\\nNo container, volume, page, etc.\\n\\n141:\\nauthor: Toynbee, Arnold J. => family \\\"Toynbee\\\", given \\\"Arnold J.\\\"\\ntitle: \\\"A Study of History\\\"\\nnote? There's \\\"abridged by D. C. Somervell\\\" => maybe editor? Actually abridged by is like editor? The schema has editor field (array of strings). So editor: [\\\"D. C. Somervell\\\"]? Or note? Let's put in note? But there is specific \\\"abridged by D. C. Somervell, New York: Oxford (Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History).\\\" The publisher is Oxford? Actually \\\"New York: Oxford\\\" => publisher_place \\\"New York\\\", publisher \\\"Oxford\\\". The parenthetical \\\"(Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History)\\\" is part of title? Or note? Let's include in title? Actually title is \\\"A Study of History\\\". The rest is publication info and note. Let's parse:\\npublisher_place: \\\"New York\\\"\\npublisher: \\\"Oxford\\\"\\neditor: [\\\"D. C. Somervell\\\"]? The field is \\\"editor\\\" array of strings. Yes, abridged by can be considered editor.\\nnote: \\\"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\\\" maybe in note.\\nBut also there is \\\"(Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History)\\\" right after publisher. Let's assign note: \\\"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\\\". Or include in title? Probably note.\\n\\nLet's do:\\nid \\\"141\\\"\\ntype \\\"book\\\"\\ntitle \\\"A Study of History\\\"\\nauthor [{\\\"family\\\":\\\"Toynbee\\\",\\\"given\\\":\\\"Arnold J.\\\"}]\\neditor [\\\"D. C. Somervell\\\"]\\npublisher \\\"Oxford\\\"\\npublisher_place \\\"New York\\\"\\nnote \\\"Abridgement of vols. I-VI of A Study of History\\\"\\n\\n142:\\nauthor Verberne, L. G. J. => family \\\"Verberne\\\", given \\\"L. G. J.\\\"\\ntitle \\\"In den spiegel van het verleden: historische opstellen\\\"\\npublisher_place \\\"Utrecht, Antwerpen\\\"\\npublisher \\\"Bruna\\\"\\ntype \\\"book\\\"\\n\\n143:\\nauthor Vevir, Jos\u00e9 => family \\\"Vevir\\\", given \\\"Jos\u00e9\\\"\\ntitle \\\"Esquemas de metodolog\u00eda eclesi\u00e1stica\\\"\\npublisher_place \\\"Barcelona\\\"\\npublisher \\\"Instituto\\\"\\ntype \\\"book\\\"\\n\\n144:\",\"refusal\":null,\"role\":\"assistant\",\"annotations\":null,\"audio\":null,\"function_call\":null,\"tool_calls\":[]},\"seed\":null}],\"created\":1786804098,\"model\":\"thinkingmachines/Inkling\",\"object\":\"chat.completion\",\"service_tier\":null,\"system_fingerprint\":\"default\",\"usage\":{\"completion_tokens\":2048,\"prompt_tokens\":2697,\"total_tokens\":4745,\"completion_tokens_details\":null,\"prompt_tokens_details\":{\"audio_tokens\":null,\"cached_tokens\":0}},\"prompt\":[]}"}, "scoring": {"fuzzy": 0.0, "cost_summary": {"total_input_tokens": 13485, "total_output_tokens": 10240, "total_tokens": 23725, "input_cost_usd": 0.013484999999999999, "output_cost_usd": 0.041471999999999995, "total_cost_usd": 0.05495699999999999}}, "normalized_score": 0}